One Post, Two Post, Write Post, Read Post

Right on time for his birthday, I thought it would be appropriate to go with a Dr. Seuss quote for my blog banner this month. The blog banners that I have made so far can be found (and downloaded, they are all under Creative Commons licenses) from my Flickr account.

I also think it’s a bit of a sharp relief to some of the more serious discussion that I’ve been aiming for in my posts as of late. But I really need to be careful not to have too much silliness. The idea that librarians are a silly profession has been floated over on the Annoyed Librarian’s blog. I’m simply thankful that the profession has a well combed stereotype of no-nonsense hair-in-a-bun book worm frowning shushers to counteract any possible notion that we are possibly silly or even potentially fun. While I am concerned that the video in question may be the first time in the history of mankind a child has been coached on camera to say things that they have no possible way of knowing the definition, it’s comforting to know that the threshold measurement for silly in librarianship has been lowered to the point where it can also exclude the possibility of silly hats, ugly shirts, and all but the most droll humorous wording in our advertisement flyers. The online librarian community should be an uproar, limiting the damage of this damning video by unlinking from blogs and sites that show it, for this one short highly edited lighthearted conference ceremony video could give the populace the idea that we are not serious professionals worthy of their tax money. I mean, look at it! It’s as if the videos of Rob Lowe having sex, Marion Barry smoking crack, and David Hasselhoff extremely drunk eating hamburgers combined into one giant “librarianship is serious business” Waterloo. This could possibly be the worst thing to ever happen to the library ever. Nevermind that we invite people everyday to use their imaginations through our materials; we are merely the dealers and should never ever be the users.

Did anyone watch this video and think that the era of serious weddings was over? Um, NO. And neither will that video of a three year old “digital native”.

But I digress.

Keep these words by Roald Dahl, spoken by his character Willy Wonka.

“A little nonsense now and then is relished by the wisest men.”

As for those who are appalled by this (dare I say it?) cute video, if you are really taking this video that seriously, you might be due for a little nonsense right about now. Because if you are considering this video as a real issue, then you are ignoring the hell out of actual serious issues such as reaching out to the community served, advocacy on issues of support and funding, and education as to the mission and materials of the library. And, quite honestly, articles and posts regarding what it means to be a serious librarian (or, apparently more importantly, what is not part of one) creates discussion that resembles a circular firing squad; it is to the benefit of no one.

In case anyone still wants to press the point about how the VALA video is such a detriment, please first consider this video before responding. I think it sums up my thoughts on your position in the most succinct and correct manner.

6 thoughts on “One Post, Two Post, Write Post, Read Post

  1. shame on you for rickrolling your readership…

    I think that AL crossed a line in this posting- I’ve enjoyed, up to a point, some of the mockery that has characterized his/her writing up to now, but this one, and the sheer contempt in the comments, was revolting. In medieval times, the jester was given a considerable latitude in order to fulfill their role of pricking the monarch’s grandeur- but in the end, their tiny heads were cut off.

    • I find the comments section of the AL’s blog to be far more loathsome than what it written above it. It reminds me of all the partisan political comments I read on news blogs (like Jake Tapper’s Political Punch) that are just pure bile.

      People have asked me why I read the AL and it’s like this: I read it because you should read professional blogs that you tend to disagree with. It’s how you dismantle the echo chamber and get a feel for other people’s perspectives. And sometimes, I find myself in agreement; this also reminds me that there always exists a common ground.

      As for the Rickrolling, nothing like a little reminder as to what other content exists on YouTube when people start acting in a humorless fashion. =D

  2. Thanks for posting this. I actual didn’t even watch that video that was floating around until you posted it. I didn’t realize the controversy either.

    Did librarians really think she wasn’t coached? I thought they did, but if they are unlinking, and I supposed shunning the video, I guess they didn’t.

    I don’t think that makes us a silly profession for the video, but silly if you are unlinking it because she was coached. She’s three. I thought it was coached when I first saw the first posting, but I never watched the video until now.

    • The casual connection between the video (and the underlying arguments presented) and professional irrelevance is breathtaking in the hang time to jump to that conclusion.

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s