The Spaghetti Sauce Moment for Libraries

This isn’t the first time I’ve featured this TED talk on my blog. To summarize the salient points for the purposes of this post, Gladwell talks about the epiphany of multiple “perfect” spaghetti sauces. While researchers were baffled by the feedback regarding what constituted the best sauce, it was only when the data points were clustered into groups that the realization that there were multiple answers became apparent. It’s one of the reasons we have a variety of flavors and types in our food products these days and extends well beyond the spaghetti sauce market.

I think it is long overdue that the same epiphany should be applied to how the profession imagines the role and design of the public library. The traditional model of library service relies heavily on formats and mediums as the product or service of the library. Even recently, deviation from this approach leaves to the professional outcry when libraries go bookless or turn more towards community center facilities and offerings. For all the lamenting and teeth gnashing that goes into the condemnation, there seems to be little (if any) thought given as to whether or not these changes are meeting the needs of the community that they serve. In whining about the death of the traditional library, what is overlooked is whether this meets a core principle of public librarianship: serving the changing needs of the community.

This brings me back to the idea of multiple “perfect” spaghetti sauces. For all the standardization that occurs within the profession and the tired call of “All libraries should do X” of the conference circuit speakers and presenters, public libraries are still very local reflections of their communities. In trying to be ‘everything to everyone’, the public library is in danger of becoming important to no one. Our professional loyalties should be with access and service, not formats and mediums. Our core constituency are the people for whom there are gaps in information and knowledge access. If these needs can be met by turning the library into (what some would call) an internet café, then so be it. If it means ignoring ebooks and digital resources in favor of print books and materials, then so be it. What matters here is the community, not the expectations or opinions of remote colleagues or antiquated notions as to what a public is or is not.

We as a profession have arrived in an age when one size no longer fits all when it comes to information access. Rather than looking to the outside for validation, librarians need to look into their communities and adapt accordingly. Just as there is no single perfect spaghetti sauce, there is no single perfect design and execution of the public library.

7 thoughts on “The Spaghetti Sauce Moment for Libraries

  1. As someone who just now made dinner using Rao’s jarred spaghetti sauce (relatively expensive, but worth it!), I have to say Bravo! to this post. I think you are absolutely correct. Rao’s may work for me, while Ragu or Prego or Paul Newman may be on the menu for another. And of course, there’s my homemade sauce that compares to no other.

    I do believe that community is the key, not our collections in whatever format. I think you nailed it. Thanks for a great post.

  2. Pingback: It’s a wonderful life–library edition « bringyournoise

  3. Ditto to what Brad said. I get so tired when people try to take that one-size-fits-all mentality to academic libraries. What works at Widener Library won’t necessarily work at my library, and vice versa.

  4. Great post, Andy! You are absolutely right about this, as are those who said it also applies to academic libraries. The key is getting to know your community and soliciting feedback. It’s amazing how good the local community feels when their voice is heard, and their opinions and needs are being used to help guide decisions. For lack of a better term it’s a win win situation.

  5. Pingback: 100 Days of Websites, day 15 » John Klima

  6. Pingback: Organise | Pearltrees

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s